docs: Add technical audit findings to README — core CSI pipeline returns random data #62

2026-03-01T17:32:00+08:00

deletexiumu commented

2026-03-01 17:32:00 +08:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Summary

This PR replaces the misleading README with an evidence-based technical audit showing that the core implementation is non-functional.

Why This PR Exists

Issue #29 (the original audit) was deleted by the maintainer
Multiple community issues (#11, #12, #21, #27, #39) reporting the same problems have been closed or deleted
The maintainer has a documented pattern of suppressing criticism rather than addressing technical concerns

Key Findings

Finding	Evidence
CSI parsing returns `np.random.rand()`	`v1/src/hardware/csi_extractor.py` L83-84, L128-142
Hardware reads return hardcoded strings	`v1/src/hardware/csi_extractor.py` L323-326
Doppler estimation is random noise	`v1/src/core/csi_processor.py` L390
No trained model weights exist	Zero `.pth`/`.pt` files, zero training scripts
"94.2% accuracy" is fabricated	Impossible without trained weights
Star inflation suspected	8,365 stars / 35 commits, overnight jumps documented in Issue #12
Author self-admitted	Commit titled "Make Python implementation real - remove random data generators"

Cross-Verification

Claude: 1/10 — "AI-generated facade with placeholder core"
Codex/GPT-5.2: 1/10 — "At best a scaffold; at worst intentionally deceptive"
Gemini: 0/10 — "Non-functional fake project designed to manufacture influence"

Note to Maintainer

Instead of deleting this PR (as you did with Issue #29), please address the technical findings. The evidence is permanently preserved at https://github.com/deletexiumu/wifi-densepose and will be resubmitted if removed.

Note to Community

If this PR gets closed/deleted without addressing the findings, that itself is additional evidence of suppression. The maintainer has been frequently deleting issues and PRs that expose these problems.

You can report this repository for misleading metadata (fake stars violate GitHub ToS):

Click "..." menu on the repo page → Report repository

Full audit: https://github.com/deletexiumu/wifi-densepose

All claims are verifiable by reading the source code at the cited file paths and line numbers.

## Summary This PR replaces the misleading README with an evidence-based technical audit showing that the core implementation is non-functional. ## Why This PR Exists - **Issue #29** (the original audit) was **deleted by the maintainer** - Multiple community issues (#11, #12, #21, #27, #39) reporting the same problems have been closed or deleted - The maintainer has a **documented pattern of suppressing criticism** rather than addressing technical concerns ## Key Findings | Finding | Evidence | |---------|----------| | CSI parsing returns `np.random.rand()` | `v1/src/hardware/csi_extractor.py` L83-84, L128-142 | | Hardware reads return hardcoded strings | `v1/src/hardware/csi_extractor.py` L323-326 | | Doppler estimation is random noise | `v1/src/core/csi_processor.py` L390 | | No trained model weights exist | Zero `.pth`/`.pt` files, zero training scripts | | "94.2% accuracy" is fabricated | Impossible without trained weights | | Star inflation suspected | 8,365 stars / 35 commits, overnight jumps documented in Issue #12 | | Author self-admitted | Commit titled "Make Python implementation real - remove random data generators" | ## Cross-Verification - **Claude**: 1/10 — "AI-generated facade with placeholder core" - **Codex/GPT-5.2**: 1/10 — "At best a scaffold; at worst intentionally deceptive" - **Gemini**: 0/10 — "Non-functional fake project designed to manufacture influence" ## Note to Maintainer Instead of deleting this PR (as you did with Issue #29), please address the technical findings. The evidence is permanently preserved at https://github.com/deletexiumu/wifi-densepose and will be resubmitted if removed. ## Note to Community If this PR gets closed/deleted without addressing the findings, that itself is additional evidence of suppression. The maintainer has been **frequently deleting issues and PRs** that expose these problems. You can report this repository for misleading metadata (fake stars violate GitHub ToS): - Click "..." menu on the repo page → Report repository Full audit: https://github.com/deletexiumu/wifi-densepose --- *All claims are verifiable by reading the source code at the cited file paths and line numbers.*

Pull request closed

Please reopen this pull request to perform a merge.

Sign in to join this conversation.

1 Participants

Notifications

Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: dearsky/wifi-densepose#62